Methadone vs. Buprenorphine for addiction…

Methadone detox 6

There has been much controversy for decades over the treatment of opioid addiction.  Methadone has been the mainstay, along with detox, rehab counseling and perhaps outpatient behavioral modification.  Methadone has its advantages, such as low cost, and it quite effectively suppresses cravings for heroin and other opioids.  The problems with methadone are numerous however, such as the need to show at the clinic daily for sometimes megadoses of liquid methadone.  This is a problematic area.  Even in profound addicts, methadone is so powerful that the clients become somnolent and then are released to drive themselves home, or wherever.  Methadone is indeed a powerful agonist just like heroin, oxycodone, morphine, fentanyl, etc.  So such psychic effects should not be unexpected, even though the somewhat slower onset of action of methadone mitigates this side effect a bit.  Other very significant side effects involve pregnant methadone users, who deliver babies highly dependent on the opioid and must be routinely treated with weaning doses of an IV opioid in the neonatal intensive care nurseries, often for weeks or months at tremendous taxpayer expense.  Finally, methadone is most usually considered simply a replacement therapy for heroin, etc.  It is not viewed except, under rare circumstances, as a stepping stone to finally being opioid free.

Suboxone has been touted as a worthwhile alternative to methadone.  It is a weak partial agonist with a threshold effect.  While methadone and other potent opioids can be taken to a point of severe respiratory depression and fairly rapid death, Suboxone cannot, unless the patient consumes with multiple other concurrent drugs such as alcohol, benzos, and other sedatives, even these cases are unusual.  The relative safety of Suboxone allows for the writing of a prescription that frees the patient up from daily visits to the Suboxone center.  Also, it appears to be just as effective in craving suppression as methadone, but without the somnolence and adverse effect on neonates born to addict mothers.  Time spent in neonatal intensive inpatient care is minimal in comparison to methadone users during gestation – saving taxpayer monies.  Naturally, the drug model of treating opioid addiction in isolation does not succeed forever, except in unusual circumstances, unless combined with appropriate psychotherapy; this can take the form of group therapies, IOPs, solo CBT, etc.

There is little doubt that Suboxone treatment of opioid addiction will supplant methadone treatment eventually.  The long term financial future of methadone clinics is therefore very murky at best.

About Dr. Michael J. O'Connell, PainCare, New Hampshire
Dr. Michael J. O’Connell, PainCare, New Hampshire, was born and raised in the tri-city area. After graduating from the University of New Hampshire and Dartmouth Medical School, he served honorably for seven years in the US Army to include residency training at the Presidio of San Francisco. Last stationed at Ft. Bragg, NC, he achieved the rank of Major, was airborne trained and was listed for Lieutenant Colonel. In 1992, Dr. O’Connell founded PainCare (formerly Northeast Pain Consultation), which has since grown to 12 locations throughout New Hampshire. Today, Dr. O’Connell, who no longer practices medicine, is the CEO of PainCare overseeing all operations. Professional Certifications & Associations: Dr. O’Connell is a former member of numerous professional organizations including the American Academy of Pain Management, the American Pain Society, the International Spine Injection Society, the Society for Pain Practice Management, the American Society of Interventional Pain Physicians, the American Society of Anesthesiologists, the American Academy of Pain Medicine, and the American Medical Association. Education  B.A. in Biochemistry from University of New Hampshire  M.D. from Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, NH  Internship at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Washington DC  Residency in Anesthesiology and Pain Management at Letterman Army Medical Center/University of California, San Francisco  Master’s degree in Health Administration (MHA), University of New Hampshire

Comments are closed.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 56 other followers

%d bloggers like this: